Complete Guide to Rollovers as Business Start-Ups (ROBS)

Potential Risks and Disadvantages

View Table of Contents

While Rollovers as Business Start-Ups (ROBS) can be an attractive option for funding a new business venture, it’s crucial to approach this strategy with a clear understanding of the potential risks and drawbacks. ROBS isn’t a one-size-fits-all solution, and like any financial decision, it comes with its own set of challenges and considerations. In this section, we’ll explore the key risks and disadvantages associated with using ROBS to fund your business. By examining these factors carefully, you’ll be better equipped to make an informed decision about whether ROBS aligns with your business goals and risk tolerance. Let’s delve into the potential pitfalls you should be aware of before proceeding with a ROBS arrangement.

Risking retirement savings

One of the most significant drawbacks of using Rollovers as Business Start-Ups (ROBS) is the inherent risk to your retirement savings. When you opt for ROBS, you’re essentially betting a portion—or potentially all—of your nest egg on the success of your new business venture.

Retirement accounts are designed to provide financial security in your later years, and they benefit from compound interest and tax-advantaged growth over time. By using these funds to start a business, you’re removing them from this protected environment and exposing them to the volatility of entrepreneurship.

Statistics show that a considerable number of new businesses fail within the first few years. If your business doesn’t succeed, you could lose not only your current income but also the financial cushion you’ve built for retirement. This double jeopardy situation can be particularly devastating, especially if you’re closer to retirement age and have less time to rebuild your savings.

Moreover, even if your business is successful, there’s no guarantee that it will generate returns comparable to what your retirement account might have earned if left untouched. The stock market, despite its fluctuations, has historically provided solid long-term returns for retirement portfolios. Your business, on the other hand, may take years to become profitable or may never reach the level of returns you hoped for.

It’s also worth considering the opportunity cost. By using your retirement funds now, you’re missing out on potential market gains and the power of compound interest. This could significantly impact the size of your retirement nest egg when you eventually need it.

Click to view Key Takeaways & Tips

Key Takeaways

ROBS puts your retirement savings at risk of loss if the business fails.
You may miss out on potential market gains and compound interest.
Rebuilding retirement savings can be challenging, especially later in life.
Business returns may not match long-term stock market performance.

Tips

Only consider using a portion of your retirement savings, not the entire amount.
Have a backup plan for retirement in case the business doesn’t succeed.
Consult with a financial advisor to understand the long-term implications.
Consider your age and years until retirement before making this decision.
Explore other funding options that don’t put your retirement at risk.

Complex setup and ongoing compliance requirements

While Rollovers as Business Start-Ups (ROBS) can provide a valuable source of funding for new entrepreneurs, it’s crucial to understand that this financing method comes with its share of complexities. The setup process and ongoing compliance requirements demand careful attention and often necessitate professional assistance.

The initial setup of a ROBS involves several intricate steps. You must form a C Corporation, create a new 401(k) plan for your business, roll over funds from your existing retirement account, and use those funds to purchase stock in your new corporation. Each of these steps requires precise execution to comply with Internal Revenue Service (IRS) regulations and avoid potential penalties.

Once your ROBS is established, the compliance requirements continue. You’ll need to maintain detailed records, file annual reports, and ensure your business adheres to all corporate formalities. This includes holding regular board meetings, keeping minutes, and maintaining a clear separation between personal and business finances.

The 401(k) plan you create as part of the ROBS structure also requires ongoing management. You’ll need to administer the plan in compliance with Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA) guidelines, which include non-discrimination testing, filing Form 5500 annually, and providing required disclosures to plan participants.

Moreover, you must be vigilant about avoiding prohibited transactions. The IRS closely scrutinizes ROBS arrangements, and any misstep could result in disqualification of your 401(k) plan, leading to significant tax consequences and penalties.

Click to view Key Takeaways & Tips

Key Takeaways

ROBS setup involves multiple complex steps
Ongoing compliance is crucial for maintaining ROBS structure
401(k) plan administration adds another layer of responsibility
IRS scrutiny necessitates meticulous record-keeping and adherence to regulations

Tips

Consider hiring a ROBS provider to guide you through the setup process
Consult with a tax professional familiar with ROBS structures
Implement a robust system for tracking and managing compliance requirements
Stay informed about any changes in ROBS-related regulations
Regularly review your ROBS structure with a qualified advisor to ensure ongoing compliance

Potential for IRS scrutiny

When considering Rollovers as Business Start-Ups (ROBS) as a funding strategy, it’s crucial to understand the potential for IRS scrutiny. While ROBS is a legal method of funding a new business, it does attract attention from tax authorities due to its complex nature and the use of retirement funds.

The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) closely monitors ROBS transactions to ensure compliance with tax laws and regulations. This heightened scrutiny stems from concerns about potential abuse of retirement accounts and the tax-deferred status of these funds. The IRS wants to verify that ROBS arrangements are not being used as a means to improperly access retirement savings or circumvent tax obligations.

One of the primary reasons for IRS scrutiny is the potential for prohibited transactions. These are actions that could benefit the business owner personally at the expense of the retirement plan. For example, using the retirement plan to pay excessive salaries or renting property to the business at inflated rates could trigger an IRS investigation.

Another area of concern for the IRS is the valuation of the company’s stock. When retirement funds are used to purchase stock in the new corporation, the IRS wants to ensure that the valuation is fair and reasonable. Overvaluing the stock could be seen as a way to extract more money from the retirement account than is justified.

The IRS also pays close attention to the ongoing operation of the business and its adherence to ROBS rules. This includes monitoring whether the business maintains a legitimate retirement plan for its employees and whether it follows proper corporate governance procedures.

It’s important to note that while the potential for IRS scrutiny exists, it doesn’t mean that every ROBS transaction will be audited. However, the possibility of an audit or investigation should be taken seriously, as it can be time-consuming, stressful, and potentially costly if violations are found.

Click to view Key Takeaways & Tips

Key Takeaways

ROBS transactions are subject to heightened IRS scrutiny.
The IRS is primarily concerned with prohibited transactions and fair stock valuation.
Ongoing compliance with ROBS rules is essential to avoid IRS issues.
The possibility of an audit or investigation should be considered when choosing ROBS.

Tips

Work with experienced professionals who specialize in ROBS transactions.
Maintain meticulous records of all ROBS-related activities and transactions.
Regularly review and update your ROBS arrangement to ensure ongoing compliance.
Consider obtaining a third-party valuation of your company’s stock to support its fairness.
Stay informed about IRS guidelines and any changes in regulations related to ROBS.

Limitations on salary and personal asset protection

When utilizing a Rollovers as Business Start-Ups (ROBS) strategy, entrepreneurs must be aware of certain limitations regarding salary and personal asset protection. These restrictions are in place to ensure compliance with IRS regulations and to maintain the integrity of the ROBS structure.

Salary limitations are a crucial consideration for business owners using ROBS. The IRS closely scrutinizes the compensation of ROBS participants to prevent abuse of the system. As a result, business owners cannot simply pay themselves an exorbitant salary from the funds rolled over from their retirement accounts. Instead, they must adhere to what the IRS deems as “reasonable compensation” for their role in the company. This means the salary should be commensurate with industry standards and the specific duties performed by the owner.

Furthermore, in the early stages of the business, owners may need to limit their salary or even forgo it entirely to ensure the company has sufficient capital to operate and grow. This can create personal financial strain, especially if the business takes longer than expected to become profitable.

Regarding personal asset protection, ROBS users face some unique challenges. While incorporating the business as a C Corporation provides some level of personal asset protection, the use of retirement funds in this manner can potentially expose personal assets to greater risk. If the business fails, not only do owners lose their investment, but they may also have depleted a significant portion of their retirement savings.

Additionally, because the business owner is both a shareholder and an employee of the corporation, there can be complications in maintaining the “corporate veil” that typically separates personal and business liabilities. This blurred line between personal and business finances can potentially make it easier for creditors to pierce the corporate veil in legal disputes, putting personal assets at risk.

Click to view Key Takeaways & Tips

Key Takeaways

ROBS participants must adhere to “reasonable compensation” guidelines for salaries.
Owners may need to limit or forgo salaries in the early stages of the business.
Using retirement funds for ROBS can increase personal financial risk.
The dual role of shareholder and employee can complicate personal asset protection.

Tips

Consult with a ROBS specialist or tax professional to determine an appropriate salary structure.
Maintain clear documentation of all business decisions and transactions to support the separation between personal and business finances.
Consider additional insurance policies to protect personal assets.
Regularly review and adjust your salary as the business grows to ensure it remains reasonable and compliant.
Explore other funding options in conjunction with ROBS to diversify risk and maintain some retirement savings.

Go to Previous Section

Go to Beginning

Go to Next Section